Mountain Project Logo
To save paper & ink, use the [Hide] controls next to photos and comments so you only print what you need.

The Misunderstanding

5.9, Trad, 160 ft (48 m), 2 pitches,  Avg: 3.1 from 161 votes
FA: Dave anderson, Randal Grandstaff 1975
Nevada > Southern Nevada > Red Rocks > (16) Black Velv… > Whiskey Peak > N Face
Warning Access Issue: Red Rock RAIN AND WET ROCK: The sandstone is fragile and is very easily damaged when wet. DetailsDrop down

Description

The Misunderstanding starts about 50' left of Mazatlan. Look for a crack in a corner running through dark varnished rock.Pitch 1- climb easy ground, up slightly sandy white rock. Aim for the obvious cracks on the right side of the corner. Traverse left under the roof and pull over the top, onto the belay ledge, belay from 2 good bolts(70'- 5.9).Pitch 2- The meat of the route!! Climb the obvious varnished crack that you've been admiring!! At the top of the crack is another white roof, climb right under the roof to reach another short wide section. Once you reach the corner of the roof you'll see the next anchor, which is semi-hanging.To descend rappel the route with 1 rope(50M).

Protection

SR- doubles in the 3 TO 4.5" size's

Photos [Hide ALL Photos]

Mo crushing p-2 of The Misunderstanding.
[Hide Photo] Mo crushing p-2 of The Misunderstanding.
The Misunderstanding
[Hide Photo] The Misunderstanding
Tybo following "The Misunderstanding".
[Hide Photo] Tybo following "The Misunderstanding".
View from the first belay.
[Hide Photo] View from the first belay.
First belay with view of 2nd pitch
[Hide Photo] First belay with view of 2nd pitch
Belaying p2.
[Hide Photo] Belaying p2.
Jonny on P-1 of The Misunderstanding. Awesome route!
[Hide Photo] Jonny on P-1 of The Misunderstanding. Awesome route!
Jonny on P-1 of The Misunderstanding. One of my favorite routes in BVC.
[Hide Photo] Jonny on P-1 of The Misunderstanding. One of my favorite routes in BVC.
Jonny leading up pitch 2 of "The Misunderstanding" on the first day of summer, June 21st, 2005.
[Hide Photo] Jonny leading up pitch 2 of "The Misunderstanding" on the first day of summer, June 21st, 2005.
Photo from the base of pitch 1 about to enter the crux.
[Hide Photo] Photo from the base of pitch 1 about to enter the crux.
Incredibly fun route; figuring out the best way to traverse under the roof
[Hide Photo] Incredibly fun route; figuring out the best way to traverse under the roof
The second pitch has no dull moments. I love this climb!
[Hide Photo] The second pitch has no dull moments. I love this climb!

Comments [Hide ALL Comments]

meo
[Hide Comment] These two pitches can be done in one and you can just reach the (easy to downclimb) start with a 70 meter rope from the top. You can easily place four to five #3 Camalots two 3.5s and two #4s or you'll need to keep bringing the pro with you. Nov 7, 2006
smassey
CO
[Hide Comment] kinda takes the fun out of it, doesn't it now? Apr 3, 2009
Nathan Scherneck
Portland, OR
  5.9
[Hide Comment] We were able to get down from the upper anchor with one single 70M rope rappel. It required some easy 4th class down climbing.

The 2nd pitch corner will take Black Diamond #3s or #4s well. Jan 11, 2012
[Hide Comment] The bolted anchors on this route were retro-anchors, courtesy Todd Swain. They were installed when Todd was putting in his nearby routes Perplexity and Miss Conception, original anchor atop P2 was fixed natural pro.

While attempting to switch out a homemade angle iron "cracked hanger" Swain hanger (so-called because they were made at home by Swain, and had cracks at the time of installation at the clip point-Swain still installed them) at the first belay, my party got the pleasure of snapping one of the 3/8 belay bolts at the threads. This is becoming a common occurance-the same experience was had two weeks ago on Triassic's P2 anchor, seems like Swain may have bought a bad batch of bolts at one point, or mixing metals has caused more galvanic corrosion than expected with the angle iron and cold shut hangers that were installed with these bolts. We did not bring the whole replacement kit, therefore the first anchor is one bolt currently, judging from the one beside I wouldn't trust it by itself.

Both anchors will be replaced with solid stainless very shortly. In the meantime, bring a 70M or swing right to the Miss Conception P1 anchor if you'd like to avoid a short low-fifth downclimb. This was replaced last year and is solid stainless. The mess it was before replacement made the Misunderstanding anchors look good...

UPDATE: Both anchor stations are replaced with bomber ASCA stainless. You can donate now if you're feeling thankful- Sep 3, 2012
Patrick Mulligan
Reno, NV
 
[Hide Comment] How folks rate the a 2 star climb I simply don't understand. This thing is old school and classic! Mar 16, 2013
[Hide Comment] Doing it as one pitch is a blast. I took up two 4s and two 3s and thought that it still protected well. Jan 5, 2017
bmdhacks
Bellingham, WA
 
[Hide Comment] As a budding 5.10 leader, I found the first pitch protected fine with doubles of C4s. I'd climb it with a single rack if I had to. Very thoughtful interesting climbing.

I easily could have placed three #4's and four #3's on the second pitch, and my double set felt really inadequate. Pretty much walked my pieces the entire climb, which was a bit of a hassle.

Rapping on a single 70 brings you below your first placement on the first pitch, and there's a ledge to come off rappel before an easy downclimb. Mar 22, 2017
Fernando Cal
SLC, UT
  5.9
[Hide Comment] Great climb! Good hand jams, laybacks, stems, all options are there. I did a combination of all three for great fun! Used four BD#3 and 1 BD#4. Another #4 wouldve been nice, but it was sitting nice and warm at the bottom inside my pack. Bolted anchors with rap rings. Good route for the grade Apr 17, 2017
Alex Fletcher
Las Vegas
 
[Hide Comment] Did this with 2 #3’s and 1 #4. Felt runout to me but then again this was my first 5.9. You can place a #2 and #3 metolius in the seam in the roof of pitch two extended with a double before traversing and going up the “final short wide section” which is easy to the anchors. Dec 12, 2017
Mike Horan
Bishop, CA
 
[Hide Comment] Fantastic sustained 5.9 mostly-crack climbing. Both pitches were 4 stars to me.

Has anyone tried to continue up and top this out? It looks like there's another decent 5.8ish pitch above the anchors. Then maybe 5.11/12? Jan 19, 2019