|
|
Taylor Krosbakken
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Duluth, MN
· Joined Nov 2008
· Points: 1,086
I replaced an old SMC hanger recently that had been up for probably close to 30 years.
It was fairly corroded, and with their reputation, I was curious what it would fail at. A few of my friends and I took some guesses.
Before I reveal the results, any guesses from the MP crowd?
Edit: I have been locked out. I will post results tonight when I'm allowed to post again. Yes I used the original bolt too. I found a nut that matched threads and clamped it to the aluminum plate. The bolt did not fail. Orientation doesn't matter. The hanger doesnt know if its upside down :)
|
|
|
Long Ranger
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Boulder, CO
· Joined Jan 2014
· Points: 669
I going in on this with complete naivety not knowing it's reputation - yes it looks rusty, but also fairly beefy and pretty modern - would clip. So, ~10kn. At least.
|
|
|
Peter Thomas
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Denver, CO
· Joined Jul 2018
· Points: 350
that looks like one of the slightly newer fatter SMC Hangers. 8KN?
|
|
|
Taylor Krosbakken
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Duluth, MN
· Joined Nov 2008
· Points: 1,086
Not the newer style. First gen. Horizontal logo.
|
|
|
Brian 1
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Vista / Oside
· Joined Aug 2017
· Points: 0
I'm going to go low, that looks pretty rusty. 5KN.
|
|
|
Dirtbag Darvo
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Apr 2018
· Points: 10
|
|
|
Mitchell Moreland
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Cincinnati, OH
· Joined Mar 2017
· Points: 0
|
|
|
Zacks
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Apr 2015
· Points: 65
wasn't the issue with those 1st gen smc ones that they where prone to cracking? I can't see if there is a crack in that picture so my guesses are:
if there is no visable crack 17kn
if there is a visable crack 2.5kn
|
|
|
Taylor Krosbakken
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Duluth, MN
· Joined Nov 2008
· Points: 1,086
To give you a hint... or lead you astray....
Here is a hanger of similar vintage, same design, less rust, from not too far away:
I have heard third hand reports here on MP and in books that these can fail under body weight. Hence the "death hanger" moniker.
|
|
|
Taylor Krosbakken
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Duluth, MN
· Joined Nov 2008
· Points: 1,086
Zacks wrote: wasn't the issue with those 1st gen smc ones that they where prone to cracking? I can't see if there is a crack in that picture so my guesses are:
if there is no visable crack 17kn
if there is a visable crack 2.5kn
No visible crack, but kind of hard to see with all the corrosion.
|
|
|
curt86iroc
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Lakewood, CO
· Joined Dec 2014
· Points: 274
|
|
|
Taylor Krosbakken
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Duluth, MN
· Joined Nov 2008
· Points: 1,086
curt86iroc wrote: 1 kn Bob.. NO PRICE IS RIGHT RULES!!!! sorry for yelling.
|
|
|
curt86iroc
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Lakewood, CO
· Joined Dec 2014
· Points: 274
|
|
|
Taylor Krosbakken
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Duluth, MN
· Joined Nov 2008
· Points: 1,086
|
|
|
curt86iroc
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Lakewood, CO
· Joined Dec 2014
· Points: 274
ok.... 6 kN
do i still get the power boat?
|
|
|
Zac Barr
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Apr 2002
· Points: 10
what was the rating 30 years ago when new? I guess just a little less than that
|
|
|
Exiled Michigander
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined May 2018
· Points: 252
|
|
|
sonvclimbing
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
bolder city
· Joined Dec 2008
· Points: 25
4.321894367 kn
What does the winner get?
|
|
|
Taylor Krosbakken
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Duluth, MN
· Joined Nov 2008
· Points: 1,086
|
|
|
Matt N
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
CA
· Joined Oct 2010
· Points: 476
|
|
|
Alan Zhan
·
Sep 12, 2019
·
Seattle, WA
· Joined Jul 2013
· Points: 161
|