Bear Activity in the Adirondacks
|
A story and some advice for climbers who do a lot of camping in the Adirondacks... |
|
It should be noted that there's been one or two instances of BLACK bear attacks (deaths to humans) in the last hundred years. [for those unaware, we only have black bears in the East/Northeast] |
|
Did you use real bear spray or human mace? |
|
Most deaths are the result of selfies nowadays (edit- let's not limit that to bears alone). I would disagree with black bears are fearful of us. Most are, one where I go to school takes a dead sprint at the sound of a person. Our consensus after seeing this bear walk within 10 ft of us a few times was that she was comfortable around humans from exposure, and potentially feeding, and had no fear of people. Obviously the usual tactics are less effective since they have figured out that we won't bother them if they just grab good and go, except where mace is involved. |
|
Nick- bear mace of course. Human mace is illegal in NY, I think, besides it has less range, spread and is less potent |
|
Thought that stuff was called bear spray not mace? Just wondering how well it worked? spent most of the summer in bear country out west and the bear spray was a great psycological comfort. |
|
Nick Goldsmith wrote:Thought that stuff was called bear spray not mace? Just wondering how well it worked? spent most of the summer in bear country out west and the bear spray was a great psycological comfort.Same thing yeah. I think its strictly speaking Bear Counter Attack and Deterrent or something if you want to be technical. It sprayed a gray cloud accurately at a range of 20-30 ft, and the bear would immediately turn and run off, we heard it hacking a few times and saw it licking its nose afterwards. Only need a fraction of a second's worth of spray for it to work. Even the lingering traces of it in the air were enough to cause varying reactions in us, mostly tearing up and some coughing, so with the thought of getting it directly sprayed in our eyes, mouth and nose would probably have us on the ground uncontrollably crying and coughing. Bears have a sense of smell something like 150% times greater than ours IIRC, so it must have been extremely unpleasant to say the least. It also lingers with them, we could smell her coming a few times when the mace started wafting in the air again. EDIT- to reiterate its potency, some of it got on the tent, and even after washing it out, the occupants (luckily I wasn't one) would still sometimes start coughing randomly for a few days after |
|
Bear spray was marketed very agressivly arround yellowstone. You could rent it for $9.00 a day at kiosks in the park. we bought ours in the wall mart in Cody after reading the posters advetising bear spray displayed on main street. A great comfort while hikeing up garnet canyon a 2:00am as well as helping us feel warm a fuzzy sleeping in sketchy truck stops.. |
|
Aren't bear canisters mandatory in the Dix Wilderness? I have scratches on my can from bears encountered Mt Colden Outpost. I let the bear play around with the can until he/she gave up. Didn't have to mace the bear but I used a can. |
|
Bill Kirby wrote: Aren't bear canisters mandatory in the Dix WildernessI believe only in the eastern high peaks. But they should be mandatory in more places/zones within the Park, especially Spring, Summer, and Fall. |
|
Nolan Huther wrote:I would disagree with black bears are fearful of us.You're alive, so she feared you enough to not make you dinner. Realistically, a 200+ pound black bear could kill a human. The fact they don't run when trying to get our food is more out of habituation and hunger, not instinct. Her instincts tell her to stay away from us/be leery of us. I fear dying in a car crash (instinct), but I still drive a car (necessity). |
|
Bill Kirby wrote: Aren't bear canisters mandatory in the Dix Wilderness? I have scratches on my can from bears encountered Mt Colden Outpost. I let the bear play around with the can until he/she gave up. Didn't have to mace the bear but I used a can. When I've been in grizzly or Brown Bear land. I carry a S&W 500 or AR-15 Beowolf or nothing. Mace is a fucking joke to a brown or grizzly bear. I was at Chapel Pond yesterday. I worry for the bears' life in today's crowded Adirondacks.Like Kevin said, they are not required in the Dix, but I would recommend them. As for your incident, I wouldn't have maced her either but with the growing bear problems in the Adirondacks I do wonder if it's better to do so to reinforce the instinct that you don't mess with humans or their stuff. It probably didn't decide one day it was OK to be around humans, it was probably an accumulation of low level encoutners without any consequences that build up to being more accustomed to dealing with humans. I can see having a weapon like that for extended periods of time or if I lived out in that country, especially where they outnumber the human population or Alaskan expeditions, but for an overnighter or very short backpacking trip where there's less exposure or sparser populations I think I'd fine with bear spray. It's been well documented that grizzlies and brown bears are affected by spray in the same way black bears are, even mountain lion attacks have been stopped by bear spray. It's not mosquito repellent repellent we're talking about. Bear spray is a nonlethal way to discourage a small number of attacks, and if you leave immediately, you're problem will probably go away. Thankfully that's not something we have to worry about here! I do hope that bear isn't shot, but relocation could be realistic if this behavior continues or worsens. What's worse is that the cubs are learning from the mother |
|
Bill Kirby wrote: When I've been in grizzly or Brown Bear land. I carry a S&W 500 or AR-15 Beowolf or nothing.Pics of you backpacking with an AR-15? |
|
Bill Kirby wrote:Mace is a fucking joke to a brown or grizzly bear.I tend to think of it as de-incentivizing the food reward of messing with you/your stuff. If the bear feels it isn't worth the trouble to mess with you they'll move on. In areas with a high prevalence of human/bear interactions, many bears know what bear spray is and will get out of there as soon as they hear the aerosol. On the other hand, a wildlife ranger in Denali once told me that he has seen them licking it off each other... I've heard of people carrying white kitchen trash bags in their pocket. Pull it out and shake it around if you see a bear. Such an unnatural sound/color can supposedly freak them out. Nolan Huther wrote:-mace the bear only if it is being aggressive/intimidating, especially if it is threatening (growling moving fast towards you, standing on its hind legs).This is actually a pretty common misconception. Both black and grizzly bears will stand on their hind legs in order to get a better view of their surroundings and this is not typically an aggressive stance. Source Save the bears, use bear cans! |
|
Kevin Heckeler wrote: You're alive, so she feared you enough to not make you dinner. Realistically, a 200+ pound black bear could kill a human. The fact they don't run when trying to get our food is more out of habituation and hunger, not instinct. Her instincts tell her to stay away from us/be leery of us. I fear dying in a car crash (instinct), but I still drive a car (necessity).I would refer you to the rest of the post you quoted from me, where I say most are fearful, and that I am making exception to this bear. Of course it is entirely true what you said. Our consensus after seeing this bear was that she wasn't acting in any particular way towards us other than nonchalance, and that she acted as if it wasn't there. She even started opening a pack in front of us instead of running off with it first (until we maced her). One person in our group has been backpacking and climbing out West and in Alaska for over a decade and had encounters with grizzlies and brown bears often, and never had to mace (or shoot) them. It was his assertion that this bear had the least fear of humans (edit- or the most suppression of fear) he had seen. It behaved almost like a cat than a bear from the time we were in its presence. An alarming change in behavior, very unnatural. |
|
Nolan Huther wrote: I would refer you to the rest of the post you quoted from me, where I say most are fearful, and that I am making exception to this bear. Of course it is entirely true what you said. Our consensus after seeing this bear was that she wasn't acting in any particular way towards us other than nonchalance, and that she acted as if it wasn't there. She even started opening a pack in front of us instead of running off with it first (until we maced her). One person in our group has been backpacking and climbing out West and in Alaska for over a decade and had encounters with grizzlies and brown bears often, and never had to mace (or shoot) them. It was his assertion that this bear had the least fear of humans (edit- or the most suppression of fear) he had seen. It behaved almost like a cat than a bear from the time we were in its presence. An alarming change in behavior, very unnatural.Exception noted. :-D |
|
Nolan, were you using the Pacific Coast Trail bear hang technique? |
|
Mother with 2 cubs? Saw her right up near the Beer wall area a week ago. we were cooking breakfast at the pullout and she walked into the middle of the road and we had to shoo her away so there wasn't an accident. |