Misogynistic and problematic route names in rock climbing
|
I just read this very insightful article from the CBC on problematic route names in rock climbing. What are your thoughts on the pervasiveness of crude and inappropriate rock climbing route names? I had a long talk with my partner and we agreed that trying to promote a systematic renaming of sexist and misogynistic routes is the way to go. That's the only way our sport can truely become inclusive and equitable. |
|
Stick to the gym if you want to get the warm fuzzies from route names. Or if you cant climb without pc names on your routes you could put up some climbs with family friendly names, or just complain about it on the proj.... |
|
|
|
I just want to see a list of climbing's most offensive route names |
|
William Fleming wrote: I just want to see a list of climbing's most offensive route names A couple related threads https://www.mountainproject.com/forum/topic/111601467/route-name-negro-girls?page=3 |
|
William Fleming wrote: I just want to see a list of climbing's most offensive route names Yes Paul. Please enlighten the people here on MP. A list would be appreciated.Thx |
|
Please excuse me while I go and climb "Harry Butthole Pussy Potter" or perhaps I'd rather try "Flabby-armed Spanking Machine" or maybe "Anal Sac Expression". OP should go try "Man Junk"! These are all at HCR in arkansas, and there's plenty more where that came from! |
|
"Problematic" |
|
I find it confusing that some cultures must be protected while others are eradicated and that’s ok. |
|
Find a new hobby. |
|
Misogyny is so 2016. |
|
It's ironic that even climbing apparently needs gentrification. |
|
I think there is some ego in putting up a route in that the person that put it up probably wants it to see some climbs. Giving it a wild or vulgar name is a quick easy way to make it stick out or make it memorable. Would people rather climb Juggy Boulder Face Climb #2 or Pussyfart Express? How many Becky-whoever routes are there? How many North ridges are there? I don't think there is any malice. |
|
Paul Park wrote: I just read this very insightful article from the CBC on problematic route names in rock climbing. What are your thoughts on the pervasiveness of crude and inappropriate rock climbing route names? I had a long talk with my partner and we agreed that trying to promote a systematic renaming of sexist and misogynistic routes is the way to go. That's the only way our sport can truely become inclusive and equitable. I'm not opposed to this but don't feel too strongly about it. Yes the route names are misogynistic but more than anything they are childish (says a lot about the first ascentionists). I feel like an idiot when I tell someone, "hey I just sent [insert childish misogynistic route name]". That said, I think our community needs to be way more inclusive so im not opposed to renaming routes that keep people away |
|
The idea that anyone needs to be "protected" from IDEAS that they find upsetting is not just problematic, it's blatantly anti-democratic. Can you really not see the slippery slope this represents? |
|
Its an art that the average millennial doesn't understand or appreciate. Try the local stitch and bitch club? |
|
Real bigotry of any type is motivated by a sense of aggression or fear towards another group. This is different from having a sense of humor. I would speculate that most healthy people have a sense of humor about one another. I don't think that men have cornered the market on this. They've just climbed more. |
|
route names usually just happen. they have something to do with what went down that day . if the name ends up being childish then the FA party gets to live with that for the rest of their lifes… what you think is funny at 20 might not be so cool when you grow up a bit but that's how life unfolds.. |
|
|
|
Over the years I have made lots of topos in San Diego. So many times climbers who did some boulder problem give me some offensive name expecting that I will put that on MY map. When I don't, they act hurt like I am censuring them. I tell them that if they are so proud of the name they want then go over to Mountain Project and post up the name there. Take personal credit for the route name. So far, nobody ever has. Free speech means the government cannot arrest you for a vulgar statement or piece you write or painting you make. Privately owned platforms like Facebook, MP or any other person's publishing efforts do not have to promote your stupidity. You are free to do that on your own. |
|
Mountain Project is offensive and not inclusive. Some climbers are actually afraid of heights. Thus, the name of this site is triggering to them. Change it already. |