Tony's Nightmare 

This is in great and fat condition right now. Start at the base of a small ice step then hike to the first pitch. It is max WI 2+ if the easy line is done, but climb further left and there is is a pretty fun looking and stout pillar. A long hike takes you to the second pitch. This is probably WI 3 right now, but if you climb on the right side, it is max WI 2 and again the further left the steeper...still not WI 4... IMHO.
Above is another long easy but super fun pitch of WI 2-.
Rapping is easy with one rope. Rap slings with rings are abundant on all trees.

This was my second pitch of ice climbing ever (TRed) and I wanted to submit something on the ice section. My first was the lower ice section along the approach (same gully). It was good enough for me to want to swing axes again. Anyway, there is a sling anchor for a descent to the left of the flow.

A fixed TR anchor exists as some slings and biners 15ft left of the top.

Ice is not as fat as in the pic above from Feb 02, but quite wet and plastic. It should form up some more w/ colder temps here. The gully below is in the same soft condition, but neither are thin by any manner. Snow depth in the gully is low and conditions are stable from brief inspection (no weak interface layer).

Nice ice and hearty approach, but the I-70 traffic is a little annoying to hear all day long.

FYI, after reading the beta on the sling anchor, it is note worthy that there is a good bolted anchor with shuts for TR and rapping, it's a bit higher up from the sling anchor, on the left, look for a giant boulder.

Just for some reasonable clarification: Tony Nightmare is WI3 50' The lower approach ice is WI2+ 60'. You can bypass the lower ice to the left by working up slabs and thin ledges. The avi danger in there is super exposed. Tons of wind-loading happens way above in the upper gullies. The ice above the main WI3 pitch rambles at WI2- 100' and trees with old tat and rings abound to rap from.

Conditions over Easter Weekend were good. The nightmare was the approach. A 1000-1500 feet of slogging through snow and scree. Ice was solid. 1st pitch is easily soloed, W12+ maybe, pitch two a bit farther up. It's the work, maybe 40-50 ft of WI3-4. Pick your line. Belay to the left to avoid ice and rock fall. Next pitch involves some WI2+ climbing, with some snow slogging, solo it. Ropes really are only needed for descent. If you make it to P3, might as well shoot for the summit and get a little alpine experience. Snow slope was stable on 5 MAR. Ice was solid and took long screws. All in all, a ton of work for some minimial climbing. The Shroud seems a better bet based on the approach and about the same quality of ice. IMHO the "Nightmare Tony had" was the horrendous approach. Slings and rap rings abound on all trees. As always, watch for avy danger as the entire climb is in an avy chute.