I thought the route was great for a first trad lead. Low stress, easy climbing. Good route for getting acquainted with placing pro. It is chossy, though, in some places. Tread lightly through the upper bit of the pitch, especially.
Thought this was really good fun, and the rock isn't bad at all. Perhaps the comments above came from another similar climb? We climbed some anonymous horror around the corner thinking it was Penny Lane, about 5.4-5.5, but VERY loose and chossy. I can't find details of it in Handren's book or on here. Penny Lane itself was fun, and super clean in comparison.