This route hates me... Not sure what its deal is but I am going to say that the rock smoothes out as soon as I touch it. So in my defense I say it is 5.hard!! No but seriously just took my first lead fall ever on the first bolt. Got scared, bailed and went and led Face in the Muck or whatever on the back side.
My buddy did lead this, said it was scary, but he climbed it no problem. I say rating is right, I am just weak.
As Joseph said, this now has 4 bolts and seems like it no longer deserves the PG13 rating. Enjoyed this a lot, and have to disagree that it's easier than Gutterballs. Thought it required a bit more thought.