Login with Facebook
 ADVANCED
Muira VS - slight Morton's toe
View Latest Posts in This Forum or All Forums
Page 1 of 1.  
Follow replies to this topic? Notify me at the top of web site.
1

Email me.
 
Feb 24, 2013
Polish Traverse (V5-7)
Hey
I'm looking at getting the La Sportiva Muira VS's for bouldering/sport climbing (my moccs are dying after years of service).

I have a slight case of Morton's toe and wear a 10.5 (EU 44.5) and tried on a 43 (9.5) and 42 (8.5). The place I went didn't have a 42.5. The 42s are super tight, mildly painful, so I'm probably getting them unless I feel better when I find a 42.5.

Here's the question: my toes knuckled a fair amount in the 42s, but I had this feeling that the big toe wasn't jammed completely to the end. I could stand on the tips of my toes (like a ballerina LOL), so I don't think performance is going to suffer, but I just wanted to see whether not having your big toe feel flush with the shoe is common among Morton's toe "sufferers" and whether the shoe molds to fit your feet in that way, and whether performance is adversely affected by this issue? I don't want the shoe to stretch and then have a gap between the big toe and the shoe.

The Muira's feel like they would perform amazingly and I'd prefer something slightly more high-performance than the Anasazi VCS that I'm also considering. Those were great-fitting, but I feel like they'd be disadvantaged for overhanging boulders, and I'm an edge-aholic, which the Muiras felt superior for.


Thanks for any help!
Jon Frisby
From New York, NY
Joined Feb 24, 2013
34 points
Feb 24, 2013
Middle
I wonder if there are other companies that make climbing shoes? Probably not, bummer. Ray Pinpillage
From West Egg
Joined Jul 23, 2010
130 points
Feb 24, 2013
Polish Traverse (V5-7)
Ray Pinpillage wrote:
I wonder if there are other companies that make climbing shoes? Probably not, bummer.

I probably should've tried on more than two shoes - oh wait, I did
Jon Frisby
From New York, NY
Joined Feb 24, 2013
34 points
Feb 24, 2013
I also have two different sized feet, so I'm biased, but the shoes that have fit me best we the Evolv Optimus, the velcro ones. I bet the lace version would do well too. The toe box is really fat, and seems to let all my toes contact the end pretty well, even though I don't have high volume feet. dylanfllr
Joined Feb 14, 2012
3 points
Feb 24, 2013
Polish Traverse (V5-7)
dylanfllr wrote:
I also have two different sized feet, so I'm biased, but the shoes that have fit me best we the Evolv Optimus, the velcro ones. I bet the lace version would do well too. The toe box is really fat, and seems to let all my toes contact the end pretty well, even though I don't have high volume feet.

Do you have Morton's?
Jon Frisby
From New York, NY
Joined Feb 24, 2013
34 points
Feb 24, 2013
I've got Mortons and wear the muira vs. They are hands down the best shoe I've ever worn. Fits like a glove. I'd make a real effort to find a 42.5 if you can.

My big toe barely touches the end, the rest of my toes are bent slightly. If I wear a half size smaller and my big toe is bent slightly, the shoes become too tight to wear comfortably.

Ymmv, of course.
John Wilder
From Las Vegas, NV
Joined Feb 1, 2004
2,394 points
Feb 24, 2013
Yeah, on one foot. I'm from NC and my parents were cousins so my feet are all f'd up. dylanfllr
Joined Feb 14, 2012
3 points
Feb 24, 2013
Jon Frisby wrote:
Hey I'm looking at getting the La Sportiva Muira VS's for bouldering/sport climbing (my moccs are dying after years of service). I have a slight case of Morton's toe and wear a 10.5 (EU 44.5) and tried on a 43 (9.5) and 42 (8.5). The place I went didn't have a 42.5. The 42s are super tight, mildly painful, so I'm probably getting them unless I feel better when I find a 42.5. Here's the question: my toes knuckled a fair amount in the 42s, but I had this feeling that the big toe wasn't jammed completely to the end. I could stand on the tips of my toes (like a ballerina LOL), so I don't think performance is going to suffer, but I just wanted to see whether not having your big toe feel flush with the shoe is common among Morton's toe "sufferers" and whether the shoe molds to fit your feet in that way, and whether performance is adversely affected by this issue? I don't want the shoe to stretch and then have a gap between the big toe and the shoe. The Muira's feel like they would perform amazingly and I'd prefer something slightly more high-performance than the Anasazi VCS that I'm also considering. Those were great-fitting, but I feel like they'd be disadvantaged for overhanging boulders, and I'm an edge-aholic, which the Muiras felt superior for. Thanks for any help!



ems.com/product/index.jsp?prod...

Size 42.5
Greg Pouliot
Joined Jul 23, 2012
7 points
Feb 26, 2013
Polish Traverse (V5-7)
John Wilder wrote:
I've got Mortons and wear the muira vs. They are hands down the best shoe I've ever worn. Fits like a glove. I'd make a real effort to find a 42.5 if you can. My big toe barely touches the end, the rest of my toes are bent slightly. If I wear a half size smaller and my big toe is bent slightly, the shoes become too tight to wear comfortably. Ymmv, of course.

So when the shoes started to stretch, did the issue with your toe not being smashed to the end get worse, did it stay the same, did the shoe form to your foot?
Jon Frisby
From New York, NY
Joined Feb 24, 2013
34 points
Feb 26, 2013
Taken at MWV Icefest 2014.
John Wilder wrote:
I've got Mortons and wear the muira vs. They are hands down the best shoe I've ever worn. Fits like a glove. I'd make a real effort to find a 42.5 if you can. My big toe barely touches the end, the rest of my toes are bent slightly. If I wear a half size smaller and my big toe is bent slightly, the shoes become too tight to wear comfortably. Ymmv, of course.


^ +1

Same for me. Be patient and try all the sizes. After a week or two mine fit like gloves.
cjdrover
From Somerville, MA
Joined Feb 18, 2009
388 points
Feb 27, 2013
Me leading pitch 4 of Rewritten.
I don't have Morton's, but my second toe is the same length as my big toe. I had a similar problem with the Muira VS. No matter how much I downsized, my big toe never felt like it was all that tight. Every other toe could be painfully knuckled over and yet my big toe seemed like it was flat. In the end, I got Scarpa Feroces and never looked back.

Have you tried Scarpa?
Jonathan Ward
From San Francisco
Joined May 23, 2010
72 points
Feb 27, 2013
slopey
Jonathan Ward wrote:
I don't have Morton's, but my second toe is the same length as my big toe. I had a similar problem with the Muira VS. No matter how much I downsized, my big toe never felt like it was all that tight. Every other toe could be painfully knuckled over and yet my big toe seemed like it was flat. In the end, I got Scarpa Feroces and never looked back. Have you tried Scarpa?


+1 The Muira was my first love but now that I've been introduced to the Booster and Boostic I will probably never look back. Boosters are being discontinued so you may be able to snag them for an awesome deal.
Jeremy Hand
Joined Feb 24, 2012
109 points
Feb 27, 2013
Polish Traverse (V5-7)
Jonathan Ward wrote:
I don't have Morton's, but my second toe is the same length as my big toe. I had a similar problem with the Muira VS. No matter how much I downsized, my big toe never felt like it was all that tight. Every other toe could be painfully knuckled over and yet my big toe seemed like it was flat. In the end, I got Scarpa Feroces and never looked back. Have you tried Scarpa?

I've only tried one or two pairs of Scarpas. I didn't love them as much as the Muiras but maybe I just need to try on different styles. I also didn't love the rubber, and once you account for a resole it gets a little high (not to mention the fact that resoling can be hit or miss).
Jon Frisby
From New York, NY
Joined Feb 24, 2013
34 points
Feb 27, 2013
Jon Frisby wrote:
So when the shoes started to stretch, did the issue with your toe not being smashed to the end get worse, did it stay the same, did the shoe form to your foot?


I dont size my shoes tight, so I've actually never really experienced much stretching in a shoe. The Muiras dont really have alot of ways to stretch- there's not that much leather upper on them. They fit like a glove right out of the box- and stayed that way. Maybe got a tiny tiny tiny bit less tight, but not in a bad way.

I've never actually found a shoe where my big toe was curled- its short enough that the pain from my other toes curling would stop me way before my big toe curls. with a 'comfortable' curl in my toes, my big toe barely touches the end. This works fine for me, as I dont climb hard enough that my big toe needs to be curled at all.
John Wilder
From Las Vegas, NV
Joined Feb 1, 2004
2,394 points
Feb 27, 2013
Jon Frisby wrote:
I also didn't love the rubber, and once you account for a resole it gets a little high (not to mention the fact that resoling can be hit or miss).

For quite a while, Scarpa and Sportiva from similar years of production use the exact same rubber (Vibram XSV to XSGrip to the current XS Grip2 and XS Edge combo depending whether the shoe is designed more for edging or smearing). While a lot of the models have similar fit to equivalent Sportiva models in the forefoot area, the midfoot & heel tend to be a bit different.
reboot
From Westminster, CO
Joined Jul 17, 2006
143 points
Feb 27, 2013
Polish Traverse (V5-7)
reboot wrote:
For quite a while, Scarpa and Sportiva from similar years of production use the exact same rubber (Vibram XSV to XSGrip to the current XS Grip2 and XS Edge combo depending whether the shoe is designed more for edging or smearing). While a lot of the models have similar fit to equivalent Sportiva models in the forefoot area, the midfoot & heel tend to be a bit different.

oh really. it must've been a specific shoe I didn't like. I will try to check out some Boosters/Boostics. NY doesn't have a ton in the way of shoe selection.
Jon Frisby
From New York, NY
Joined Feb 24, 2013
34 points


Follow replies to this topic? Notify me at the top of web site.
1

Email me.
Page 1 of 1.  
Beyond the Guidebook:
The Definitive Climbing Resource
Inspiration & Motivation
to Fuel Your Run
Next Generation Mountain
Bike Trail Maps
Backcountry, Sidecountry
& Secret Stashes
Better Data. Better Tools.
Better Hikes!