Mudflap Girl 

After thinking a bit, I'm giving it 3 stars. Normies might give it none, but adventure geeks will have a blast. Many thanks to the FA party for all the hard work it must have been, and to Mr. Schneiter for the accurate, adequate info.

The descent, by means of the gully, can be quite hard to find. I spent a hour figuring out where the hell to rap from. So, here are some details that might help. Walk to the east most point of the gully, the rap anchors are on a tree a hundred feet in front of you on the north side of the gully. Scramble down to the anchors. THEY ARE NOT EASILY VISIBLE. watch for falling rocks because they will definitely hit the person below you. Make a 100 rap into the gully where you will find a decent 3 piece anchor with red tat. From there, rap another 100 feet and run down loose scree to two more easy raps. The 1st one is on your right, and it is 3 old pitons, and the last one is on a tree to you left. The route was fun, and I would definitely recommend it. Nice job, Chris....

Super cool, very fun route. Since I used this site as the guidebook, I thought I'd give back a bit. I did a trip report here:

web.me.com/billwright510/Mobile_Me_Site/Climbing_Blog/Entrie>>>

There is a link to tons of photos there, as well.

Unfortunately, we did not print out or read the comment about the rappel route. Our bad. We did not find it and retreated back to rap the route, which went very nicely, except for one brief, stressful moment when our ropes were stuck.

Also, here are my guesses at the pitch lengths: 120, 60-70, 50, 90, 120, 90, 50, 120, 50, 80. The protection at the 5.10 sections were good and the climbed seemed a lot easier than Pervertical on the Diamond. The 5th pitch (5.9) was the only bad pitch on the route. It is probably easier than 5.9, but it feels that hard since it is very runout, loose, and difficult to figure out exactly where to go. Also, the 2nd last pitch has a harder boulder problem on it that is probably 5.10- instead of 5.8.

Very fun adventure route. Kudos to the first ascensionists. Recommended but feels more like an alpine route.

Killer adventure and some nasty climbing.
I would call the crux pitch a bit of a sandbag at 10a. It was a hard, exposed, scary lock off.

I was able to enjoy my first climbing experiences on the Mudwall 9/25 Saturday on this route, which I thought overall was rather fantastic. Kudos to the FA party! Really enjoyable, adventurous climbing, steep and juggy in places, techy-face in others, most on very nice quality rock. The first pitch and some other is rather sandy, and with the ledges, loose rock abounds, but the vast majority of the climbing is on really cool quartzite. I see a comment about 10- sandbag, that's for sure, I see the description (now?)suggesting .10+ in the crux roof and that seemed about right to me.

Since there is still discussion of best descents and such here, I'll add what we found which may be helpful. Although we rappeled, so I have not done the 'gully descent' I will never look for this, rappelling the route seemed straightforward and the way to go.

The 2006 Rifle/West Slope guidebook lists this as a 9 pitch route, combining pitches 6 and 7 as described here on Mtn Proj. We climbed the routes in 4 full, 60 m rope lengths and one ~100' pitch which worked well, although this could create excessive drag if not atentive to this concern.

We combined p1 and p2; p3 and p4; p5 6 and 7; did p8 as described; and p9 and 10. This was relatively efficient and nice because all of the combined pitches contain interesting and fun 5.10 climbing. A little bit of moderate simul-climbing was required after the roof on this site description's crux p7 for the leader with the terrain the second simuls also being quite moderate. I think I would try to do the last three pitches as one next time which would require ~ 40' of moderate simulclimbing and allow the route to be done in 4 super fun '60m' pitches. We followed the descent beta in that same Rifle/W. Slope guide which was good and the anchors used are quite in line for the rappel (hence why I believe some appear a bit off to the climber's L for climbing). As described here, we used anchors systems 10 ('summit'), 9, 7, 5, 4, and 2.

Highly recommended route, big fun, I'm look forward to other routes here.