|
Rob Gordon
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Hollywood, CA
· Joined Feb 2009
· Points: 115
Stepped on the scale yesterday and it rang up 198. Good god. That's like 30 pounds above my ideal weight for climbing. I'm still able to climb around V5, but certainly I'm about two grades off from my personal bests, and forget certain problems that require extreme finess on tiny holds. Got me thinking. Who here weighs over 190-200 and is able to climb, let's say, V7+ or 5.13+. Not talking onsight, just two or three sessions for the send. Can it be done?? Any famous climbers who are this heavy and crushing?
|
|
Peter Franzen
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Phoenix, AZ
· Joined Jan 2001
· Points: 3,730
Klem Loskot always seemed to be on the bigger end of the spectrum. He isn't fat of course, but I would guess that he is in the 190-200lb range.
|
|
JCM
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Jun 2008
· Points: 115
Nothing tastes as good as sending feels.
|
|
Burton Lindquist
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Madison, WI
· Joined Jan 2002
· Points: 4,220
Johnny Dawes! Brit hard man climber who likes his plate full at dinner time!
|
|
Rob Gordon
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Hollywood, CA
· Joined Feb 2009
· Points: 115
Jon Moen wrote:Nothing tastes as good as sending feels. Beer sure comes close though.
|
|
FrankPS
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Atascadero, CA
· Joined Nov 2009
· Points: 276
This thread wouldn't be complete without mentioning beefy Don Whilans.
|
|
Rogerlarock Mix
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Nedsterdam, Colorado
· Joined Sep 2008
· Points: 5
If we're going to pick on Brits that are beefy and climb hard there has to be mention of John Dunne. Burly man that sends burly routes.
|
|
DB Cee
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Chattanooga, TN
· Joined May 2007
· Points: 146
Jon...you and I both know that Nutella tastes way better than any route sent in Rifle. Don't lie.
|
|
slim
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Dec 2004
· Points: 1,103
Burt Lindquist wrote:Johnny Dawes! Brit hard man climber who likes his plate full at dinner time! johnny dawes? are you sure you're not thinking of john dunne? i don't remember dawes being that big. john dunne is the obvious choice. hard scary runout 5.14 at 220+ lbs. even his RP's were scared.
|
|
Burton Lindquist
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Madison, WI
· Joined Jan 2002
· Points: 4,220
Whoops! Slim your correct. I was meaning to indicate Johnny Dunne. My bad.. was typing too quick from my desk at work and F''''d that up...
|
|
steve edwards
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
SLC, UT
· Joined May 2004
· Points: 645
Unfortunately most of these claims are exaggerated, weight wise. Lots of 200+ climb 5.13. Not too many 5.14 though that will undoubtably change as 5.14 because less close to the limit. Dunne was huge, sometimes, but he famously lost heaps of weight for his sends--like 30-40 pounds!--and was nowhere near 200 for his hard routes. Loskot is bigger than most, so he's rad, but I'll bet he's never eclipsed 2 bills either and certainly not when climbing his hardest routes. Nalle's probably 140 soaking wet. Sharma's actually the biggest climber I know at the top of the sport climbing game currently. I think it was Stevie Haston who said something like sport climbing wasn't interesting because all that mattered was how good you could get at not eating.
|
|
MountainManny
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Idaho Springs
· Joined Mar 2012
· Points: 820
Rob Gordon wrote: Beer sure comes close though. ....Or in the case of being +30> Bacon would seem more likely
|
|
Rob Gordon
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Hollywood, CA
· Joined Feb 2009
· Points: 115
MountainManny wrote: ....Or in the case of being +30> Bacon would seem more likely Haha. No. It's the beer. I probably average an extra 5000 calories a week in beer. The other factors are I stopped playing rugby for a while, so my cardio went down and so did my metabolism. I used to eat probably 30-50 percent more than I do now, but I just burn way less now. Also stopped being a vegetarian, so my muscles all got way bigger. Unfortunately my legs and ass naturally get bigger than my upper body.
|
|
Woodchuck ATC
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Nov 2007
· Points: 3,280
Saw a guy who must have been 240 and 5'9", belaying a guy who was also near 220. Leading smoothly on 5.10 is pretty impressive in my opinion. I was doubtful they could get off the ground when I saw them in Muir Valley, RRG last week.
|
|
Eric D
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Gnarnia
· Joined Nov 2006
· Points: 235
Russ Walling wrote:Since when is 200+ fat? Everyone I know is 200+ and they all climb (that would be lead "trad") at least 5.10. Anything under 200lbs is cheating unless you are an 8a.nu posterchild It all depends on height and frame obviously, but I would think that most people over 200 are overweight.
|
|
Mike Lane
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
AnCapistan
· Joined Jan 2006
· Points: 880
Just had an epiphany: for every 5 lbs. over 190 you get a letter grade handicap. At 210 that goes straight to a letter per pound. Since we all *basically* have the same fingers, it makes sense if you're pulling an extra 40 up on each hand. I'm gonna roll with that from now on. It also means I climbed a .12B yesterday
|
|
pfwein Weinberg
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Boulder, CO
· Joined May 2006
· Points: 71
Russ Walling wrote:Since when is 200+ fat? Everyone I know is 200+ and they all climb (that would be lead "trad") at least 5.10. Anything under 200lbs is cheating unless you are an 8a.nu posterchild Must be some lovely ladies in that crew!
|
|
skeeter
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Lakewood CA
· Joined Aug 2012
· Points: 10
I got married last December and am up 30lbs (191 and consider myself fat), affects my climbing when I'm on the wall dreaming about bacon.
|
|
Dylan Colon
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Eugene, OR
· Joined Jun 2009
· Points: 491
What about Dean Potter among the bigger climbers (not fat though, by any stretch). I believe that in First Ascent Steph Davis remarks that catching a 190 lb Dean Potter as he takes a 50 footer isn't that fun.
|
|
Stephen Nance
·
Aug 20, 2012
·
Boulder, CO
· Joined Aug 2006
· Points: 385
huge difference between V7 climbing and 5.13+ climbing..... I am 6'6 200 lbs, and sent my first V10 this summer, however my best on a rope is 8a....(13b)... 13+ is no joke...
|
|
JCM
·
Aug 21, 2012
·
Unknown Hometown
· Joined Jun 2008
· Points: 115
Blake Cash wrote:Jon...you and I both know that Nutella tastes way better than any route sent in Rifle. Don't lie. Truth. I recently spent an afternoon in the Arsenal doing zero climbing, and instead opted to sit around and enjoy my favorite new fat kid snack: Nutella on animal crackers.
|