Login with Facebook
 ADVANCED
Estimate the grade.
View Latest Posts in This Forum or All Forums
Page 1 of 1.  
Follow replies to this topic? Notify me at the top of web site.
1

Email me.
 
Oct 29, 2010
I'm somewhat baffled by this somewhat contrived problem.

There are 6 deep water solo routes in a cove up to 11d in difficulty. All but one of them are 11b or harder, all routes are 20 to 30 feet tall. Recently we discovered a few key holds that would allow us to traverse the entire cove, starting on the far right and finishing on the far left. The crux of each route is included in the traverse.

All the ratings in the cove are based on pure bouldering difficulty, not endurance. The 11d happens to come at the end of the traverse. Overall, the route is probably 130' long, no rests, all overhanging, and almost always in the 5.11 range.

I've recently sent this route and I'm drawing a blank as for how to rate it. On the one hand, I'll be the first to admit that the hardest move on the route is 11d or about v3-v4. Based on the number of times this route put me in the water (months of falling) and the amount of effort I needed to actually finish this route, it's plainly obvious that it's harder. It would be a joke to call this 11d. I've tentatively called it 5.12.

So the question is this, how much should endurance factor into a route? A simple sequence of 11d moves is not so simple when taken at the end of such a long route. Honestly, it felt 5.13- to me, and harder than some routes of that grade I've climbed.

I'm baffled, without ever seeing the route, please rate it for me.
Orphaned
Joined Jul 9, 2007
13,470 points
Oct 29, 2010
OMG, I winz!!!
If it were a 130foot long crack in the creek with all 5.9 moves and no rests, what would you give it?

No way I'm grading it but I think it's obvious that endurance comes into play.
Chris Plesko
From Westminster, CO
Joined Oct 18, 2007
560 points
Administrator
Oct 29, 2010
Insurrection, 5.14c.  Photo Adam Sanders.
johnL wrote:
it felt 5.13- to me


Sounds like its 5.13-.
Monomaniac
From Morrison, CO
Joined Oct 26, 2006
16,864 points
Oct 29, 2010
Bucky
Monomaniac wrote:
Sounds like its 5.13-.


No way! You see the Fat-Bat suit he's wearing! Gotta be mid 14 with that on.
J. Albers
From Colorado
Joined Jul 11, 2008
2,221 points
Oct 30, 2010
So it's all spray, no splash? Gunkiemike
Joined Jul 29, 2009
1,668 points
Oct 30, 2010
The Madness Cave at The Red comes to mind when considering this. BOHICA for instance is rated .13b and has no moves harder than around V3/4, it is simply an overhanging 100 ft. pumpfest. I think a rating in the 13- range seems fairly legitimate for what you described. Ellis Whitson
From Nomadia, Gypsyville
Joined Aug 14, 2008
106 points
Administrator
Oct 30, 2010
Courtright Reservoir, September 2013
Call it 11d but give it 5 stars Adam Stackhouse
Joined Jan 3, 2001
13,463 points
Oct 30, 2010
Stabby
Difficult route yet hard to define the grade? Tradition dictates that you tell people its .9+ Mike Lane
From Centennial, CO
Joined Jan 21, 2006
839 points
Oct 30, 2010
Mike Lane wrote:
Difficult route yet hard to define the grade? Tradition dictates that you tell people its .9+


5.9 A2
Bud Martin
From Bozeman, MT
Joined Apr 15, 2010
403 points
Oct 30, 2010
Photo by Aaron Lavinsky
I'd put the "5.12?" on it and wait till a couple people send, then go from there. RyanJames
Joined Feb 23, 2010
604 points
Oct 30, 2010
That's like asking a mechanic to diagnose a vehicle problem over the phone...



My two pennies.
Juan
no1nprtclr
From Front range Colorado
Joined Oct 31, 2006
81 points
Oct 30, 2010
J-Tree
The Car Guys rock!

But back to the original topic: I think the rating is obviously 13- if you are talking to a worse climber than you and 11d if you are speaking with a better climber.

More seriously this is related to another beef of mine: Virtually every profile on MP indicates that we climb harder sport than trad. Doesn't that mean that we should be adjusting the ratings to accommodate the effort it takes to place gear? Personally I think a trad route should be graded based on an onsight placing all gear and a sport route should be based on a redpoint after working out the moves. I think this would reflect the core values of each type of climbing. Otherwise we should just completely separtate the rating systems. [full disclosure: I enjoy both trad and sport]
David Houston
From Boulder, Colorado
Joined Nov 18, 2001
184 points
Oct 30, 2010
Imaginate
David Houston wrote:
The Car Guys rock! But back to the original topic: I think the rating is obviously 13- if you are talking to a worse climber than you and 11d if you are speaking with a better climber. More seriously this is related to another beef of mine: Virtually every profile on MP indicates that we climb harder sport than trad. Doesn't that mean that we should be adjusting the ratings to accommodate the effort it takes to place gear? Personally I think a trad route should be graded based on an onsight placing all gear and a sport route should be based on a redpoint after working out the moves. I think this would reflect the core values of each type of climbing. Otherwise we should just completely separtate the rating systems. [full disclosure: I enjoy both trad and sport]


Yeah, sport climbs are usually soft. Tell those guys to stop over grading everything. ;)
David Appelhans
From Medford, MA
Joined Nov 11, 2007
350 points
Oct 30, 2010
JohnL
You said "All the ratings in the cove are based on pure bouldering difficulty, not endurance". Also that it was contrived. Due to the fact that I've never climbed that hard, I really wouldn't know for sure but would suggest a rating of 5.11d cdwss. Which stands for 5.11d contrived deep water solo sandbag. The climbers that repeat the route will probably agree.........but then you might consider just giving it a V grade since that's what deep water soloing is IMO.
Jim Gloeckler
From Denver, Colo.
Joined Jul 7, 2004
47 points
Oct 30, 2010
Pardon me chaps, but yer off yer rocker ef you'll place a yds grade on this patch. I suggest a Rum Swizzle 6 will do fine Buff Johnson
Joined Dec 19, 2005
1,494 points
Oct 31, 2010
go with the laugh test. Give it the lowest grade you can say to your buddies out loud and keep a straight face. caughtinside
From Oakland CA
Joined Nov 21, 2006
1,898 points
Oct 31, 2010
Crux Move
Sounds to me like a 5.11d S/VS to a sweet 5.7 overhanging flake traverse 400 feet off the deck.

At least you knew you were there!
Phil Lauffen
From The Bubble
Joined Jun 20, 2008
2,113 points


Follow replies to this topic? Notify me at the top of web site.
1

Email me.
Page 1 of 1.  
Beyond the Guidebook:
The Definitive Climbing Resource
Inspiration & Motivation
to Fuel Your Run
Next Generation Mountain
Bike Trail Maps
Backcountry, Sidecountry
& Secret Stashes
Better Data. Better Tools.
Better Hikes!