Route Guide - iPhone / Android - Partners - Forum - Photos - Deals - What's New - School of Rock
Login with Facebook
Critic's Choice
Routes Sorted
L to R R to L Alpha
(Brutus of) Wyde Choice 
Barley Route 
BBC from Cleveland 
Belly Full of Bad Berries 
Break a Leg 
Bunny Slope 
Critic's Choice 
Cult Classic 
Ed's World 
Hitch Hiker's Thumb, The 
Mr. Critical 
New Life or Second Life 
Ruby Flame 
Second Choice 
Sgt. Fish Scale 
Wrench Route  
Unsorted Routes:

Critic's Choice 

YDS: 5.12 French: 7b+ Ewbanks: 27 UIAA: VIII+ British: E6 6b

Type:  Trad, 100'
Consensus:  YDS: 5.12b French: 7b Ewbanks: 26 UIAA: VIII+ British: E5 6b [details]
FA: Ruckman Bros.
Season: morning sun, afternoon shade
Page Views: 3,466
Submitted By: camhead on Mar 13, 2007
Good Page? 0 people like this page. Your opinion:   

You & This Route  |  Other Opinions (20)
Your todo list:
Your stars:
Your rating: -none- [change]
Your ticklist: [add new tick]
Buttshot of me gunning it to the anchors on Critic...


This is a super classic, super pumpy splitter. Goes from tips with quite a few feet to pumpy good fingers, a bit of off-fingers, and then a final thirty foot sprint through STEEP perfect hands to the anchors. Sometimes sandy, and usually unsullied by lame-ass chalk and tick marks.


From the approach trail's topout, go a few hundred yards to the right, then look for the most classic splitter on the cliff.


You will die if you use Bloom's gear beta of only one .5 Friend. Friends Sizes: (4).5, (3).75, (2)1, (3)1.5, (3)2.5, (2)3

Photos of Critic's Choice Slideshow Add Photo
J.A. preparing for an eventual ass-kicking on Critic's Choice.
BETA PHOTO: J.A. preparing for an eventual ass-kicking on Crit...
Comments on Critic's Choice Add Comment
Show which comments
By D-Storm
Apr 14, 2010

A good primer for Ziji's second pitch, which is also sandy but with rattly fingers. For me, the finger crack on Critic's Choice was more like flared tips than the sinker locks I usually get on yellow-Alien/Metolius-sized cracks.

By Andrew McMullin
From: Boulder, CO
Nov 1, 2011

Climbed this route on Oct 30. It was one of the best splitter cracks I've ever done and had an adventure element to it because it was sandy. At first the sand scared me, but I quickly realized that it barely affected my ability to jam. Fun to climb a route with no chalk on it. My gear beta is to bring plenty of small stuff up to green camalots, one red camalot and 3 gold camalots. Also, there is a decent warmup to the right that isn't in the book...a 5.10+ with a stone marker that is called "b.b.c. From cleveland.". It's a chimney to an interesting green camalot double crack to a #3 camalot finish. A #4 is optional for the top. Good chains.