Home - Destinations - People - Partners - Forum - Photos - What's New
 ADVANCED
Gear Review - Black Diamond ATC Guide

  [ Forums > Climbing Gear Reviews ]
  
View Latest Posts in this Forum     Page 3 of 3.  <Prev  1  2  3

 
By Rick M
From Annapolis, Maryland
Sep 27, 2007
me at the top of fairview dome in tuolumne

Galibier_Numero_Un wrote:
Out of curiosity, while at Neptune's on Saturday, I asked to compare the current XP vs. the Guide. The XP slots continue to be wide, with the Guide being narrow as we have both observed. I guess only the Guide is made in China :^) Cheers, Thom



That's cool, but I was comparing two different BD guides(no XPs). One was purchased in 2006 and the other last month. The finish is different between them and the newer model does not feed rope near as well.

By Steve Kahn
From arvada, co
Apr 23, 2008

sorry to bring up such an old thread, but i've only recently got out of the dark ages and had some other questions i thought someone might be able to help me with:

#1
was ascending up a multi a couple of months ago, and an earlier party was coming down on us. they got their ropes stuck, and one of them used their guide as an ascender to get up (using both ropes together as a fixed line). so i've done my share of jugging with prussics, a few different types of full sized ascenders, rope men, and whatever it is called when you prussic around a big beaner, but was wondering if someone had a visual of how to rig the guide as an ascender.

#2
also, thought someone might be able to help solve a debate we were having earlier that day: is it safe to belay two different people up two different ropes (top rope) simultainiously using a standard ATC? (obviously keeping hands on the brake?)...while i'm at it, what about if we were trying to move, and the first up took off to lead the next pitch, while the latter was still coming up. probably would be a big rope mess, but what about that?

thanks in advance - S

By Mark Nelson
From Coniferous, CO
Apr 23, 2008
 In a zoo in California, a mother tiger gave birth to a rare set of triplet tiger cubs.    Unfortunately, due to complications in the pregnancy, the cubs were born prematurely and due to their tiny size, they died shortly after birth. <br /><br />The mother tiger after recovering from the delivery, suddenly started to decline in health, although physically she was fine. The veterinarians felt that the loss of her litter had caused the tigress to fall into a depression. The doctors decided that if the tigress could surrogate another mother's cubs, perhaps she would improve. <br /><br />After checking with many other zoos across the country, the depressing news was that there were no tiger cubs of the right age to introduce to the mourning  mother. The veterinarians decided to try something that had never been  tried in a zoo environment. Sometimes a mother of one species will take on the care of a different species. The only "orphans" that could be found quickly, were a litter of weaner pigs.  The zoo keepers and vets wrapped the piglets in tiger skin and placed the babies around the mother tiger.<br />

Steve, #1 is a rig with the autoblock off the belay loop. Piton Pete gives an illustration but using the gri-gri. Using the guide/reverso/similar device is basically the same, but the gri-gri is far more manageable & you would need to manage a knot so you can treat a two strand standard rap as a one strand fixed to allow pull when you get to a safe anchor in a lower position.

#2 - I've actually done 2 with only munters (why? because I left my device at the anchor below). This takes practice, you can't ever take your hands off of both strands; this is something you really need to be solid with when it comes to belay technique -- it's slip, slap, slide times two and very fast. If a second falls, you really have no choice but to lock off strands -- a redirect would be helpful & recommended, if you can; even better are direct-anchor munters on separate biners.

Buddy rescue at this stage is risky to consider belay escape. So going with a basic ATC to belay two seconding climbers can turn into more than epic in a split second if your skills are not dialed in. But is it possible? Sure, you just don't have the auto-blocking rig. If the terrain is well within ability to simul-climb, using this technique works when climbing as a party of three.

Sending the leader up & belaying a seconding climber -- again, if you all could simul-climb anyway; it is possible -- but the trouble is if the seconding climber hangs, you could pull your leader off or short-rope them as you lock-off. So the risk is higher in this situation.

I would say, if the weather is moving in and you 3 had to get out of terrain, this rigging is possible to consider to try and get someone up to a safer anchor/terrain situation; but I wouldn't consider it as much an option if a fall due were likely due to terrain difficulty. You could also just have the leader short fix & keep the belay on the seconding climber independent until they reach to your anchor position.

If you didn't need to move a leader up as quickly as possible/simul-climbing wasn't likely either; what you could do instead is butterfly mid-line and use one rope and belay both seconding climbers. Use your second strand as a free tag-line if you needed to get down to them.

By zack d
Aug 2, 2008

I posted a response to this thread about how my new atc guide was very difficult to feed the rope through. I was especially bummed when belaying a leader. Well, now that the device is quite worn, it feeds much better. Maybe the holes are bigger or the coating has worn off. Anyway, now I really enjoy the device. When its time to get a new one I will break it out when i need to do exstensive rapelling....el cap?.

By Josh Brown
Aug 20, 2008

i love my guide and it's fantastic for bringing up seconds and the multi friction modes. one complaint, sort of, i was taught that if you ratchet the biner clipped through the rope that it will lower your second inch by inch in case they need only a little slack to get back to a rest. I did notice after about three weeks worth of climbing (8 days total) the biner had worn a sharp edge on the inside bottom edge of the device. something to keep your eye out for. from now on i'll just use some acc cord through the hole for short lowers


  [ Forums > Climbing Gear Reviews ]
Page 3 of 3.  <Prev  1  2  3