Login with Facebook
 ADVANCED
Bat Cave Area
View Latest Posts in This Forum or All Forums
   Page 5 of 5.  <<First   <Prev   3  4  5
Follow replies to this topic? Notify me at the top of web site.
1

Email me.
 
 
By Morgan Patterson
Administrator
Jan 22, 2013
Stoked...
David Sahalie wrote:
kinda like this guy?


just like that one... ;-)

P.S. David - I edit'd the class out for u... I'm not trying to be an 'internet' tough guy just hear/learn about problem (albeit with some sarcasm (tires)). But in all honesty, i would think people like slab know who's doing what up there and should be able to have some input or take action in some way, no?

Anyone care to name names?

FLAG
By slab
Jan 22, 2013
David Sahalie wrote:
kinda like this guy?

DAMN, that forearm vein is a FIREHOSE.

FLAG
By Williampenner
From The 505
Jan 22, 2013
Beaver Mountain
slab wrote:
DAMN, that forearm vein is a FIREHOSE.


Taping up for the workday, nice technique Slabdyno! The gorilla mask would actually reduce the fearsome look.

SWclimber, Tiny is back with Madrock now.

W

FLAG
By Senior Hernandez
Jan 22, 2013
on the trip
southwesternclimber wrote:
I hope the BLM does go in and shut the cave down. If you buy La Sportiva products you are buying the glue.



And this, once again, proves that climbers have always been climbers own worst enemies. Most of our access problems are not a result of a particular ethical choice. They are usually a result of multiple ethical beliefs, all based on dogmatism, which constantly fight for fascist supremacy.

Your last quote says all that needs to be said about the informed nature of the anti argument. Well put.

FLAG
By M Sprague
Administrator
From New England
Jan 22, 2013
Lichen head. Me, with my usual weatherbeaten, lich...
So, Tonto, what would it take to persuade you that the treatment of the cave may have been a bad idea? I suspect that nothing will and you will simply block out anything that doesn't go along with what you want to do. It is similar with fanatics on the other side like k Nichols. By the way, I think there are plenty of people who are very experienced, and not narrow minded who think (and have expressed) that the place looks like a mess. If the situation is egregious enough, I don't think being from out of state negates their opinions.

There are times to be revolutionary and break the rules, but when a large number of people are saying you are wrong, you better be willing to double and triple check yourself .

FLAG
By slab
Jan 22, 2013
maybe tonto is a noob... you should be smart enough to know diarrheaing 50 gallons of glue onto a chossy roof and turning it into a dump is stupid and wrong. its kind of common sense. where are all the advanced elite climbers sympathizing with these ethics? climbing in the bat cave? LOL.

FLAG
By Tim McCabe
Jan 23, 2013
Being strong or skilled or both doesn't give someone the right to just do as they please on public land.

I know some mountain bikers who wish this wasn't the case. Just because someone has the balls to ride a big drop doesn't give them the right to head into the forest and start cutting trail, and building features.

Riders have been fined for building, and even just for riding on bootleg trails. One rider was banned, from an entire ranger district, for 6 months for unauthorized trail repairs.

Seems to me that this level of construction is the same as trail building. I may be a has been who'll never go to the Bat Cave, but I do know something about what it takes to get permission to do construction on public land.

If this level of modification is typical of new sport area's I can't imagine it will be long before land managers feel the need to step in and require climbers to do a full NEPA for new area's.

FLAG
By Healyje
Jan 23, 2013
girl40
Tim McCabe wrote:
Being strong or skilled or both doesn't give someone the right to just do as they please on public land.


Being strong or skilled doesn't mean they aren't dumb as a stump, either. Or completely out of touch with nature and so deeply into their own idiosyncratic private Idaho they lost all perspective. And you can tell at least the latter is the case here, if by no other means, than by the blinding self-absorption of the speaker hanger (and get a frigging nano and some sport buds, no one wants to hear your music).

In no climbing world is gluing on anything approaching this ten-gallon scale acceptable. And when the level of crag - let alone hold - comfortizing and personalization begins to resemble terraforming, even the most blind, delusional, or loyal climber should hopefully be able to recognize the situation long ago left the realm of 'ethics' and strayed hard into outright vandalism of a public resource.

This is exactly the sort of shit that gives climbing a bad rep with some land managers and, in this case, deservedly so.

FLAG
 
By Senior Hernandez
Jan 23, 2013
on the trip
HoseBeats wrote:
This post was originally a comment in Bat Cave Area I understand subtle reinforcement of fragile holds that are necessary for certain routes to be climbable. What I do not understand is the wholesale application of glue as if it is a route setting tool. I saw massive patches of glue that were not close to bolted lines, holds sculpted out of glue, glue covering features to make the line harder, and attempts to hide the glue via spray painting (which only made it look worse). Those who engaged in this abomination should be condemned and ostracized by the climbing community; this type of development has no place in the modern climbing world.



Wow, one month later, almost ten thousand views, and the first post is still the only one worth reading, so I thought it was worth reposting. The rest of the posters are mainly idiots who have never been there but continue to post about their assumptions; most of them being uninformed and flat out wrong.


There are several different conversations to be had here, and none of them are happening. Only one overarching theme: everything in the bat cave is bad, uhmk, if you don't agree with me your a homo. Really now, can't we all just get along?

FLAG
By Healyje
Jan 23, 2013
girl40
Tonto wrote:
...the assumption is constatly used as proof of ethical violations. If you actually knew why this "bolt" was there you would laugh your ass off, but you don't, so enjoy your asinine assumptions.


It's irrelevant 'why' a 'bolt' like that is there beyond making the case for how out-of-hand things got.

Tonto wrote:
...proving that emotions trump logic in these ethical debates. Why am I the one pointing this out?


Well, that could be because it doesn't have shit to do with ethics at this point. The pics and glue buckets speak for themselves to the fact the whole affair departed the realm of ethics long ago. If you're oblivious or blind to that fact then this is so far beyond a matter of ethics then you are part of the reason why climber behavior gets some areas closed permanently.

Tonto wrote:
This little debacle is in no way a proxy war for personal issues that have been raging on for years. I am so impressed with the posters knowledge of what they are posting about as well as their grace when doing so. When I start commenting on your home crag in an uniformed manner, please let me know.


Crikey, this scale of chipping, gluing, and terraforming on public land has zip all squat to do with anyone's 'issues', ethics debates within climbing, or esoteric matters which require more knowledge of the crag than the pics provide. Hey, wake the fuck up - it isn't a comparative 'local' matter - it's vandalism of a public resource plain and simple and is exactly the sort of bullshit that gets telegraphed around land managers who are now as connected as we are. Don't try to couch it as a 'local issue' or hide behind an 'ethics' smokescreen. Behavior like this jeopardizes way more than just this particular crag .

FLAG
By Williampenner
From The 505
Jan 23, 2013
Beaver Mountain
Tonto, ease up on that coffee buddy and take a deep breath.

What Hosebeats described--subtle reinforcement of [a very few] fragile holds--is probably fine with many of the posters on this thread, as are the terraces at the Bat Cave. They are a jagged mess of rebar waiting to impale someone but aren't so bad in their intent to reduce erosion and provide a decent landing. That said, the Tiny Posse has rarely reinforced, modified, chipped, filled in, or glued with subtlety. Two five-gallon buckets attest to that at the Bat Cave (and apparently three others were removed previously).

Various people have tried various ways to deal with this in the past and all have failed because a small number of folks continue to enable this kind of stuff. If you actually think any of this is over the top what would you do? Your solution seems to be screaming at beginners or those from out of state for lack of standing.

I know Hosebeats very well and you are no Hosebeats, instead you just seem like a bully.

Enjoy the crystal blue persuasion,

W

FLAG
By Miike
From MA/CT border
Jan 23, 2013
my foot
holy shit I feel like everyone on this thread owes me some beer for reading this crap.

RC.com, we have arrived!

one observation here- its a choss pile in a shitty location, the land all around it torn up and trashed by miners, not a "nature" trail for miles, most of the posters have never been there and this is the hottest thread going... RC.com BABY!!!

FLAG
By Senior Hernandez
Jan 23, 2013
on the trip
TRmasta wrote:
holy shit I feel like everyone on this thread owes me some beer for reading this crap. RC.com, we have arrived! one observation here- its a choss pile in a shitty location, the land all around it torn up and trashed by miners, not a "nature" trail for miles, most of the posters have never been there and this is the hottest thread going... RC.com BABY!!!



The most astute comment yet. But it's fun right?


Healyje wrote:
Crikey, this scale of chipping, gluing, and terraforming on public land has zip all squat to do with anyone's 'issues', ethics debates within climbing, or esoteric matters which require more knowledge of the crag than the pics provide. Hey, wake the fuck up - it isn't a comparative 'local' matter - it's vandalism of a public resource plain and simple and is exactly the sort of bullshit that gets telegraphed around land managers who are now as connected as we are. Don't try to couch it as a 'local issue' or hide behind an 'ethics' smokescreen. Behavior like this jeopardizes way more than just this particular crag .



Wow, nice example of what I was talking about and why this discussion is going so well. Care to share any more hate with the crowd? With that kind of venom I really feel that we are headed somewhere. It's all loves little man.

FLAG
By Healyje
Jan 23, 2013
girl40
Tonto wrote:
Care to share any more hate with the crowd?


I don't know, care to share anymore of the blind delusions that gets crags closed permanently?

P.S. And With regard to Rifle, that's exactly the problem when folks display poor judgment at a crag (on routes like Sprayathon and Cryptic Egyption and especially when done by name climbers) - that bad judgment then spreads to other crags, each time citing the previous example as justification and rationale for yet another occasion for the very same bad judgment call - it's like a disease.

FLAG
By Jeremy Aslaksen
From Albuquerque, NM
Jan 23, 2013
Hey "David" and "Tonto" and anyone "Else",

Why don't you come meet me for a beer in ABQ and let's discuss this?

If they won't let you in we can meet at Jamba Juice.

PM me and let's hook up.

Jeremy Aslaksen
ABQ, NM

FLAG
By Senior Hernandez
Jan 24, 2013
on the trip
Jeremy Aslaksen wrote:
Hey "David" and "Tonto" and anyone "Else", Why don't you come meet me for a beer in ABQ and let's discuss this? If they won't let you in we can meet at Jamba Juice. PM me and let's hook up. Jeremy Aslaksen ABQ, NM



Sure Jeremy, I love spending time with open minded homophobes like yourself who hurl sexual insults at people they disagree with.


Healyje wrote:
Well, that could be because it doesn't have shit to do with ethics at this point. .



Nope, just personal pissing matches. Want to measure?

Did you ever wonder why this conversation is coming out years after the fact instead of when it would have actually accomplished something? Hmmmmm. Interesting.

FLAG
 
By Jeremy Aslaksen
From Albuquerque, NM
Jan 24, 2013
So that's a no?

Figured as much for a nameless troll.

Exactly as I expected.

FLAG
By Eric Whitbeck
Jan 24, 2013
If you ignore Tonto's attempts to hijack the thread, the summary is simple. Most people on this post prefer routes to be developed with minimal amounts of glue if any. That is not radical or controversial. Most also feel public lands, specifically climbing areas are not the property of the first people with enough time to develop the routes but are a communal property and that development should follow local ethics. While the value of a mountain project thread is questionable, the consensus on this issue is not. Glue should not be a tool of development. If the crag requires buckets of glue, clean it and hope for some good rock or move on. See page 77 of Cathedral and Whitehorse Ledges buy Jerry Handren for more information.
Oh, and Jeremy thanks for the offer to buy everyone a beer.

FLAG
By Williampenner
From The 505
Jan 24, 2013
Beaver Mountain
+1 Eric--well stated.

FLAG
By Senior Hernandez
Jan 24, 2013
on the trip
Eric Whitbeck wrote:
If you ignore Tonto's attempts to hijack the thread, the summary is simple. Most people on this post prefer routes to be developed with minimal amounts of glue if any.



Ding ding ding, we have a winner!

FLAG
By Morgan Patterson
Administrator
Feb 20, 2013
Stoked...
dpmclimbing.com/climbing-video...

Just found this on DPM regarding the East Coast Chipping... really glad to see folks taking action. AWESOME!!!

Anyone know who this guy is?

FLAG


Follow replies to this topic? Notify me at the top of web site.
1

Email me.
Page 5 of 5.  <<First   <Prev   3  4  5