Login with Facebook
 ADVANCED
Alpine > Trad > Sport > Boulder
View Latest Posts in This Forum or All Forums
   Page 1 of 4.  1  2  3  4   Next>   Last>>
Follow replies to this topic? Notify me at the top of web site.
1

Email me.
 
 
Dec 11, 2012
This thread got me thinking.
mountainproject.com/v/general-...

I often hear people say that Alpine climbers are the best out there, and that sporto's and pebble wrestlers are a bunch of pussies in comparison. I see myself as a recreational climber, and I find it annoying that there is this BS about sport is just an invisible TR and this and that.

Someone in the above post said they never hear sport climbers and boulderers making these negative comments about the other, but the inverse is not true. My though on it is this... sport climbing really starts at the 5.12 level, and at that point, you have invested a shit ton of time and you could likely give a crap about someone else's opinion.

Tradsters that can't climb hard boast about how inferior HARD climbing is because the ego must fine a way to justify that someone else is better than them.
Sir Wanksalot
From County Jail
Joined Sep 29, 2011
14 points
Dec 11, 2012
Something real to say > Trolling. Jonas Salk
Joined Apr 28, 2008
20 points
Dec 11, 2012
tanuki
In an effort to get this thread started in a manner that is appropriate, I will add this:

NC Rock Climber
From The Oven, AKA Phoenix
Joined Dec 6, 2009
121 points
Dec 11, 2012
The truth hurts. mugsy
Joined Nov 22, 2011
0 points
Dec 11, 2012
In an effort to get this thread started in a manner that is appropriate, I will add this:
>


My day just of much better !! I have not had a laugh that good for a while now.

Jeff J
From Bozeman
Joined Sep 15, 2010
108 points
Administrator
Dec 11, 2012
El Chorro
So, you think it's lame that people don't give you respect for sport climbing, but then you go on to say that people who don't climb 5.12 aren't really climbing?

I got news for ya buddy - the people climbing 5.8 trad or 5.10 sport are having just as much fun as you are. Probably a lot more actually. No doubt they are more fun to be around.

Get over yourself.
Ryan Williams
From London (sort of)
Joined May 10, 2009
1,468 points
Dec 11, 2012
Ryan Williams wrote:
So, you think it's lame that people don't give you respect for sport climbing, but then you go on to say that people who don't climb 5.12 aren't really climbing? I got news for ya buddy - the people climbing 5.8 trad or 5.10 sport are having just as much fun as you are. Probably a lot more actually. No doubt they are more fun to be around. Get over yourself.


I'm not saying that I'm better than them, I'm stating an opinion about "sport" climbing. I have no issue with any of the disciplines, I just notice attitude in one direction not the other.
Sir Wanksalot
From County Jail
Joined Sep 29, 2011
14 points
Dec 11, 2012
A grey fox skull wedged in a crack 100' up on a FA...
.... Yawn.... so you guys think the Broncos got a chance against the Ravens Sunday? Glenn Schuler
From Monument, Co.
Joined Jun 24, 2006
964 points
 
Dec 11, 2012
tanuki
When I was in college I ran over a chipmunk with a forklift. Boy, was that messy.

Edit to add: Glad you liked that, Jeff. Your video is pretty funny too. BTW, what do you think about Mystery Ranch? They are located in Bozeman. I just had some dealings with them regarding a warranty issue, and I was REALLY impressed with their customer service after the sale.
NC Rock Climber
From The Oven, AKA Phoenix
Joined Dec 6, 2009
121 points
Administrator
Dec 11, 2012
El Chorro
Randy W. wrote:
I'm not saying that I'm better than them, I'm stating an opinion about "sport" climbing. I have no issue with any of the disciplines, I just notice attitude in one direction not the other.


What you fail to realize is that your "opinion" is in fact attitude in the other direction. Saying that sport climbing "starts at 5.12" is no different than a trad guy saying that sport climbing is inferior. The way you feel when trad guys put sport climbers down - that's the way you just made a whole lot of 5.10-5.11 sport climbers feel.
Ryan Williams
From London (sort of)
Joined May 10, 2009
1,468 points
Dec 11, 2012
Epic free solo with a pack on
Ben Brotelho
From Albany, NY
Joined May 4, 2011
700 points
Dec 11, 2012
Climbing to ski the Fuhrer Finger Route. Photo by ...
You said it man..nobody fucks w The Jesus! I like your style dude... Woodson
From Park City, Ut.
Joined May 16, 2009
201 points
Dec 11, 2012
Dreamweaver
who cares?

When I was growing up I surfed.

Surfers>bogey-boarders>skim boarders

I also skated a lot and

vert>street>mini-ramp>roller-gayders doing anything.

It's human nature to attempt to set oneself apart from others based on their own subjective opinion.

... I digress.


A 20 hour day on an alpine route > driving to the crag, walking 5 minutes and clipping bolts.

That's just physics, brah.
Dave Bn
From Fort Collins, CO
Joined Jul 13, 2011
15 points
Dec 11, 2012
Ellingwood Point Summit, Little Bear in the backgr...
pebble wrasslin pointless little boulders is just for getting better for those RAD sport lines!
->
hangdogging up those lame safely bolted sport routes is just to get good enough not to fall off of those inspiring trad routes!
->
traddin' at the crag 30 mins from the road is just to get better so you're more confident and safe, so you can get up that huge alpine peak!
->
now you can alpine up to the tippy top of some big magestic mountain!
by the time you get here, you're old, out of shape and crusty.

lots people just skip to some random step to begin with, then/or have too much fun at whatever step they're on and stay there for the most part.


/end rambling, I had about as much of a point as the hippo.
Nate Reno
From Highlands Ranch, CO
Joined Oct 24, 2008
36 points
Dec 11, 2012
At the BRC
Randy W. wrote:
This thread got me thinking. mountainproject.com/v/general-... I often hear people say that Alpine climbers are the best out there, and that sporto's and pebble wrestlers are a bunch of pussies in comparison. I see myself as a recreational climber, and I find it annoying that there is this BS about sport is just an invisible TR and this and that. Someone in the above post said they never hear sport climbers and boulderers making these negative comments about the other, but the inverse is not true. My though on it is this... sport climbing really starts at the 5.12 level, and at that point, you have invested a shit ton of time and you could likely give a crap about someone else's opinion. Tradsters that can't climb hard boast about how inferior HARD climbing is because the ego must fine a way to justify that someone else is better than them.


I rarely hear alpine climbers putting down anybody else.
It seems to me like it's strictly a trad thing. and only a minority of trad climbers, for that matter.
Mark E Dixon
From Sprezzatura, Someday
Joined Nov 29, 2007
204 points
Dec 11, 2012
Me again!
Not understanding sport climbing: A week chufflet with a big ego but very little pain tolerance and too much fat.

Not understanding trad climbing: A noob from the gym who doesn't understand the irrelevance his situation and likes to make weak people mad.

The reward of understanding multiple disciplines: priceless.
J Q
Joined Mar 11, 2012
48 points
 
Dec 11, 2012
a good well rounded climber does sport, trad and boulders ...

if you climb harder trad, sport climbing and bouldering can be very useful to pull through cruxes ... personally every 5.12 or above trad climber i know does sport and boulders at some point ...

;)
bearbreeder
Joined Mar 1, 2009
1,876 points
Dec 11, 2012
Me again!
Ryan Williams wrote:
So, you think it's lame that people don't give you respect for sport climbing, but then you go on to say that people who don't climb 5.12 aren't really climbing?




Respect my authority!!!!!


Oh yea, it's not that they aren't climbing, it's that they aren't "sport climbing", or so I hear.

I'll bet they will come back, with a troop of boy scouts, a hemp cord, and an old swami belt.

Viva la Revolution!!!!
J Q
Joined Mar 11, 2012
48 points
Dec 11, 2012
the man was smart
Jonhy Q wrote:
Not understanding sport climbing: A week chufflet with a big ego but very little pain tolerance and too much fat. Not understanding trad climbing: A noob from the gym who doesn't understand the irrelevance his situation and likes to make weak people mad. The reward of understanding multiple disciplines: priceless.



bearbreeder wrote:
a good well rounded climber does sport, trad and boulders ... if you climb harder trad, sport climbing and bouldering can be very useful to pull through cruxes ... personally every 5.12 or above trad climber i know does sport and boulders at some point ... ;)


yep x2
T Roper
From VA,NM,UT,CT,MA
Joined Mar 31, 2006
1,053 points
Dec 11, 2012
Living the High Life.
Nate Reno wrote:
pebble wrasslin pointless little boulders is just for getting better for those RAD sport lines! -> hangdogging up those lame safely bolted sport routes is just to get good enough not to fall off of those inspiring trad routes! -> traddin' at the crag 30 mins from the road is just to get better so you're more confident and safe, so you can get up that huge alpine peak! -> now you can alpine up to the tippy top of some big magestic mountain! by the time you get here, you're old, out of shape and crusty. lots people just skip to some random step to begin with, then/or have too much fun at whatever step they're on and stay there for the most part. /end rambling, I had about as much of a point as the hippo.


X2. This is wise, young ones.
Andy Novak
From Golden, Co
Joined Aug 22, 2007
322 points
Dec 11, 2012
Cut! Sadly my flash attempt met with dismal pump-f...
Everyone has a certain mix of enjoyment from difficult movement (let's call this "movement") and from danger/exposure/conditions/gear/everything else (let's call this "adventure").

People who place a high value on Adventure tend towards the alpine/trad end of the spectrum, and people who place a high value on Movement tend towards the sport/bouldering side. I'm talking preference here, not skill level - there are boulderers who are also great mountaineers, and Alpinists who could out-crank the best gym-broulderers around.

Most people, though, tend to be best at their preferred style, and a bit below-average in other styles, which is where envy comes into play... in both directions. The part of you-no matter how small-that craves adventure, will envy hard-core alpinists. Conversely, the part of you that appreciates hard and aesthetic movement will covet the V-hard fingers of dedicated boulderers.

If you feel inferior according to one metric, the natural reaction is to apply the other metric to restore your superiority. This type of recipro-spray happens every day, at every crag/mountain/gym, and should be unsurprising by now.

What IS surprising is that we actually (to use the original poster's words against him) "give a crap about someone else's opinion." Without going too far into the irony of complaining that sport climbers are too self-assured to deserve ridicule… clearly there is something else at play here. Why do we care so much about what different types of climbers think, and why do we keep forgetting that these judgment-passers use a different standard than ourselves?

This is, I think, the reason:

Divergence. Over the years, bouldering has gotten more bouldery, sport climbing has gotten more sporty, gym climbing has gotten more artificial (and way cooler), and trad/alpine climbing... well I don't know much about trad and alpine. Divergence is awesome and exciting, and it means that climbing is progressing on multiple fronts. It also means that the average climber understands less and less about what attracts people to other disciplines.

At the same time we all continue to define ourselves as climbers, and identify as part of a larger climbing community. We don't realize (or else we constantly forget) vastly different the disciplines have become. For instance, I do the bouldering/sport/gym thing, and I consider myself a climber. If I'd grown up in the days of rusty pitons, swami belts, and hip-belays, I don't think I'd have been a climber - maybe a recreational gymnast, or more likely, a couch-potato. I just don't have the huge cojones that guys from that era had (and still have). There are personalities who are climbers now, who would not have been just a short while ago, and yet we all still think of ourselves as climbers.

In conclusion, next time you feel like bashing another discipline, or complaining that you're being hated on, stop and ask a more interesting question: What does that person like about climbing that is different from what you like? After pondering that, carry on bashing and spraying, because those are some of the last activities every true climber enjoys.
Rajiv Ayyangar
From Portland, ME
Joined Jun 22, 2010
234 points
Dec 11, 2012
Don't forget that the ultimate goal of every climber is the top of mount Everest. Everyone that doesn't get there is a failure. DannyUncanny
From Vancouver
Joined Aug 27, 2010
78 points
Dec 11, 2012
I eat crack for breakfast.
I don't think the "greater than"/"less than" symbols are logically appropriate, but the correct statement uses a "subset" symbol. I'll call this "c" for lack of a better way to write math on Mountainproject, and arrive at a factual statement describing the skill sets:

Bouldering c sport c trad c alpine.

Provided the skill of moving crash pads and spotting friends falling from boulders is not included, then we have reached an accurate statement of fact. Now, instead of worrying about self-worth if you're not an alpline climber, you can worry about whether or not Zermelo-Fraenkel set theory is an accurate description of reality, you can worry about the countability of alpine skill sets, and after enough time you'll again worry about self-worth as you spend your free time writing mathematical nonsense on Mountainproject forums.
Alex Washburne
Joined Apr 29, 2010
63 points
Administrator
Dec 11, 2012
Me and the offspring walking back to the car after...
That alpine shit is cold- definitely not for pussies. I've noticed 'tude in almost every discipline. Attitude comes from assholes, not from disciplines.

I would also like to add that the goddamned Big Lebowski divergence that every thread seems to devolve into lately is absolutely wonderful.
Jake Jones
From Richmond, VA
Joined Jul 30, 2011
997 points
 
Dec 11, 2012
eureka ha
Dave Bn wrote:
who cares? When I was growing up I surfed. Surfers>bogey-boarders>skim boarders I also skated a lot and vert>street>mini-ramp>roller-gayders doing anything. It's human nature to attempt to set oneself apart from others based on their own subjective opinion. ... I digress. A 20 hour day on an alpine route > driving to the crag, walking 5 minutes and clipping bolts. That's just physics, brah.

What fucking planet you from?!?!


Street>park>fruit booters
mozeman
Joined Dec 17, 2010
109 points
Dec 11, 2012
Epic free solo with a pack on
Yeah...street skating is way superior to vert skating. Ben Brotelho
From Albany, NY
Joined May 4, 2011
700 points


Follow replies to this topic? Notify me at the top of web site.
1

Email me.
Page 1 of 4.  1  2  3  4   Next>   Last>>
Beyond the Guidebook:
The Definitive Climbing Resource
Inspiration & Motivation
to Fuel Your Run
Next Generation Mountain
Bike Trail Maps
Backcountry, Sidecountry
& Secret Stashes
Better Data. Better Tools.
Better Hikes!