My partner and I climbed Hobbit Book a few days ago and I got the joy, if you can call it that, of leading the 3rd pitch. I'm generally fine on runout face climbs and onsight around 5.8-5.9. I checked the book before heading out into the sea of patina flakes, but once I hit the bolt, the line going straight up looked to be extremely thin and much harder than moving left. So I went left and tiptoed further and further from the bolt until I could barely see the quickdraw. I found a placement for an offset nut in a seam and a red C3 in an undercling not far away. I highly doubt either would have held a fall. I wandered mostly left of the seam, pulling a few 5.8 moves and found a grey X4 placement in a finger crack. It probably would have held. Finally I found a pod with a thin crack above it that took 3 small nuts, 20-25 feet left of the normal 3rd belay station. I built a belay and brought my partner up. Above and right was an easily protectable flake that led to the base of the final dihedral.
I know I was between Middle Earth and Hobbit Book, I could see the "cave" mentioned down and left of me. Looking at the R/F guide, I was directly below the 5.8R final variation of Middle Earth, most likely along the traverse that connects Middle Earth and Hobbit Book.
Once we got down, I asked around the meadows but nobody had ever heard of a climb going up and left of the bolt. I'm curious if anybody has. The crack I found was grassy and I didn't see any evidence of anybody having climbed up that way (no bolt holes or pin scars). Any ideas? I can type up a better description of the line we took if needed. I'll try to post a pic too with the line I took drawn in.
csproul
·
Aug 24, 2015
·
Pittsboro...sort of, NC
· Joined Dec 2009
· Points: 330
Not to sound like a jerk, but on a line that sees hundreds of ascents per year, many by noobs who get off-route, it is unlikely that you found a "new" variation to HB. One of my all time favorite climbs btw.
People have climbed out that way for years, I know one guide who goes over there regularly. Adding it to a guidebook would be sketchy due to the marginal pro and wandering line (not to mention delicate flakes).
Fair nuff. I'm not worried about an FA to be frank, I just wanted some info because I couldn't find any in the meadows. Anything you share would be nice.
Greg Barnes wrote:Cool, you had a fun time exploring! People have climbed out that way for years, I know one guide who goes over there regularly. Adding it to a guidebook would be sketchy due to the marginal pro and wandering line (not to mention delicate flakes).
Lol Greg, it was quite the learning experience. I definitely don't recommend going that way but for some reason it looked easy to me.
cs: you didn't sound like a jerk, we both kind of doubted it hadn't been done, but a provocative title gets results. :P
We use cookies to improve your browsing experience, to show you
personalized content, and for statistical purposes. By continuing
to navigate our website, you accept our use of cookies. Read our
Privacy Policy to learn more.