I don't think you have to go all the way over to the arete and back on the 3rd; there's a direct line up a thin crack that leads to the dihedral much closer to the belay.

I thought that doing it direct felt like 5.11-, and protection was poor.

the red line on pitch three is wrong going into the left facing corner. take a thin crack(not visible until your basically in it)almost directly below the corner

Thanks for the feedback... I thought the way we did it was 10+ and slightly runout. I remember seeing that thin crack, but I wasn't sure if that was the correct path.

Has anyone climbed the thin crack going straight up on P2? It looked like in would be in the 5.11 range.