Login with Facebook
Mike Amato firing the wild crux of Modern Times.  ...
Id# 105799180, 1199 x 1500px View full size
Comments on Photo (Copy) Add Comment
By Benjamin Chapman
From: Small Town, USA
Aug 5, 2013
No doubt that's a proud move over the bulge, but you're right, Mike, it isn't 5.8+. And that's because the ratings at The Gunks are skewed. Everyone knows it, but it's a local tradition to sandbag the ratings. Anywhere else in the climbing world this "5.8+" would be rated 5.10b. Time for one of the the guidebook authors to go climb in El Dorado Canyon, Indian Creek, Vedawoo, Yosemite, Joshua Tree, Squamish, Red Rocks, and/or Cathedral Ledge and get a feel for what a consensus 5.8+ (or 5.10b) is. Ask Henry Barber, Todd Swain or Lynn HIll, who traveled extensively.
By David Stowe
Aug 11, 2013
Benjamin I really think that it is what you are used to The overhang on Modern Times is definitely not 5.10. As a matter of perspective I do much of my climbing at the Gunks. On a trip a few years back to Red Rocks I found the 11.b roof pitch on Levitation to be easier than the 5.9 chimneys on Epinephrine. Those Red Rock grades are accurate, I just have much more experience and better technique on overhangs. I had waited a while when I first started leading to do Modern Time's, being intimidated by its reputation, but when I finally led it I found it to be quite reasonable. Another big difference in other places is that routes can be bolted or mixed. Very often a bolt in a convenient location makes a world of difference in how a route feels if you don't have to stop and place gear in the middle of the crux. Having been to many of the places that you named I initially found grades to be stout in those places till I became used to the rock and the climbing. I still find Cathedral to be graded stiffer than the Gunks.
By Gunkiemike
23 hours ago
I did this pitch today (17 years after the last time I did it), and I threw my left toe into the hole just as he's doing here. NO WAY in the world is that sort of nonsense a 5.8 move. Not here, not anywhere. Solid 9, and I've been to areas where it would be 10a.
Photo 3 of 16
Avg Score   3.2 from 5 votes
Your Score   

Mike Amato firing the wild crux of Modern Times. Can you believe this move is only rated 5.8+?

Submitted By: Ron Olsen on Feb 21, 2006
On this route:
Modern Times (5.8+ 5b 16 VI- 15 HVS 4c )
 Printer View

Photo Of: Michael Amato
This image is a link to another image.

Beyond the Guidebook:
The Definitive Climbing Resource
Inspiration & Motivation
to Fuel Your Run
Next Generation Mountain
Bike Trail Maps
Backcountry, Sidecountry
& Secret Stashes
Better Data. Better Tools.
Better Hikes!